I actually have a few comments to make. Firstly, thanks, Anna for complimenting my post and giving me a little plug, and secondly, Dona, you're superpower comments were not just spot on, but also highly amusing.
Thirdly, your co-worker was indeed wise with her advice about regrets. As for the other thing she said...*meh*
So here's my advice: You want someone to make the decision for you, but it's really already made. Remember how we fussed around--"Go to Exeter or not go to Exeter? Why not go to someplace that offered scholarships? Why do a Master's at all?" And all we wanted was someone to say, "Just go to Exeter already!"
So I'm saying that to you. Go to Duke. You have such an amazing opportunity. Go to Duke and not Brown because you feel it in your gut that Duke is the better choice for you. And go to Duke because you have this chance, and you should take every chance you get in life. And Dona is right--as you'll notice, Dona always is--if you aren't happy doing the PhD, you don't have to continue. You're amazingly bright, and other doors will open. And if you finish the PhD and decide that you don't want to be a professor, then don't. You get to enter back into the job market with a PhD, which isn't such a bad thing in the publishing and magazine business. Just take one step at a time and you'll find your way.
So let me ask you this...wish excites you more: (a) looking at new story ideas, or (b)sitting on a couch talking about theory?
In your heart, I think you already know what to do. Just let it happen.
Have a been a little too Dr. Phil for a relatively public forum?
hey anna,
as you might suspect, i have no real help for you here, as i am as indecisive as they come. i do second your wise co-worker's observations though- one does generally find a way to be content with the way things are. to make it more complicated, i'd like to point out that her truthism about regretting things you dont do (rather than those you do) could be applied to not going into editing/braving the abyss. That said, you could always drop out of grad school to experience the abyss and also the editorial world.
in unrelated news, i totally was not talking about you when i spoke of adding photos to my next post to disguise its poo-ness. if i were referencing you, i'd have made a not-so-subtle dig about infrequent posting :-P
wouldnt it be great if you could look into the future and see how going down the different paths would turn out?? that'd be my superpower, if i could choose one, though it would be handy to have my superpower when choosing my superpower, so as to know if that was a good decision or not. :-D
dona